I've not yet heard anyone make the following simple point, least of all those who are seeking to create the 'progressive coalition' in Britain.
Sure, the Tories got the most seats. That's their argument.
And sure, the Liberals and Labour collectively got many more votes. That's the only argument they've offered in terms of legitimacy so far.
But my argument would be this: surely a coalition made up of Labour, the Lib Dems, the SDLP, Lady Sylvia (former UUP), NI Alliance Party, the Greens (and possibly Scots and Welsh nationalists too) represents a much broader and wider sweep of the UK than a simple coalition of Tories and Liberals, propped up perhaps by the DUP.
The Tory spin that such a coalition would be fragile is undone by this argument. Because the very thing that makes it fragile is the very thing that makes it democratic - plurality of representation.
Search
Don't want to post? Email me instead.
cavehillred AT yahoo.co.uk
Showing posts with label tories. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tories. Show all posts
Monday, May 10, 2010
The Dark Lord is still spinning
Lord Mandelson appears to have pulled off at least the half-chance of continuing the nu-Labour regime that little bit longer.
Perhaps this is not the wisest move for Labour. Whoever comes in must make cuts, deep and severe cuts.
And they'd have to do so propped up by at least one other party in the Lib Dems, who could walk at any time. And in Labour's case, a few assorted other fellow travellers too.
Such an arrangement would give the Liberals the PR they want (like our presidential electoral system) but would be exceedingly fragile. This appears to be the main reason why the Liberals have permitted Westminster posh boy Clegg his flirtation with the Tories.
While Brown remained in charge of Labour, he remained a block on such a Lib-Lab pact. Mandelson now appears to have unblocked that in dramatic fashion tonight. Or was it perhaps a last throw of the dice by Brown himself, putting party and country first?
Either way, it's now a live option. The Liberals need only swallow hard, suck up the approprium of the Tory press, and cut the deal.
The alternative is now to prop up a minority Tory government, as coalition was never likely there, on the basis of a slender promise to examine electoral reform.
Not an easy choice, and getting harder for Clegg by the minute. Walking away from the Tories would please his party but not the press or many of the people.
This election has made life very difficult for all three parties. And all the available options provide concern for each of those parties.
But from an Irish point of view, there's little doubt that a coalition of Labour and the Liberals which included nationalists from the Celtic fringes is a wet dream for most Irish people.
And the alternative, Tories propped up by the DUP, doesn't bear thinking about.
This will likely result in bitter recriminations one way or the other. But if those recriminations are heard loudest from the Tory press and the Cameroons, then likely Gordon Brown and his dark Lord will consider today's stunning events to be a political masterstroke.
Perhaps this is not the wisest move for Labour. Whoever comes in must make cuts, deep and severe cuts.
And they'd have to do so propped up by at least one other party in the Lib Dems, who could walk at any time. And in Labour's case, a few assorted other fellow travellers too.
Such an arrangement would give the Liberals the PR they want (like our presidential electoral system) but would be exceedingly fragile. This appears to be the main reason why the Liberals have permitted Westminster posh boy Clegg his flirtation with the Tories.
While Brown remained in charge of Labour, he remained a block on such a Lib-Lab pact. Mandelson now appears to have unblocked that in dramatic fashion tonight. Or was it perhaps a last throw of the dice by Brown himself, putting party and country first?
Either way, it's now a live option. The Liberals need only swallow hard, suck up the approprium of the Tory press, and cut the deal.
The alternative is now to prop up a minority Tory government, as coalition was never likely there, on the basis of a slender promise to examine electoral reform.
Not an easy choice, and getting harder for Clegg by the minute. Walking away from the Tories would please his party but not the press or many of the people.
This election has made life very difficult for all three parties. And all the available options provide concern for each of those parties.
But from an Irish point of view, there's little doubt that a coalition of Labour and the Liberals which included nationalists from the Celtic fringes is a wet dream for most Irish people.
And the alternative, Tories propped up by the DUP, doesn't bear thinking about.
This will likely result in bitter recriminations one way or the other. But if those recriminations are heard loudest from the Tory press and the Cameroons, then likely Gordon Brown and his dark Lord will consider today's stunning events to be a political masterstroke.
Labels:
david cameron,
Gordon Brown,
liberal democrats,
new labour,
Nick Clegg,
tories
Thursday, May 06, 2010
David Cameron is a Tory wanker who'll make Britain a police state

An Evening Standard hack blogged today that cops had raided the home of a photographer who had placed a 'David Cameron is a wanker' poster in his window.
Then the blog mysteriously disappeared, though the Daily Telegraph still links to where it once was.
So it may or may not be true.
But in case it turns out not to be true, I wouldn't want anyone to get the wrong impression.

David Cameron IS a wanker. Worse, he's a self-entitled Tory wanker who'll make Britain the sort of police state where the cops will tear your door down for dissenting.
Call-me-Dave wasn't so precious when he and his Bullingdon Club pals were busy trashing restaurants like posh-boy hooligans at Oxford. Why the thin skin now?
Please God don't let this PR creature and his hordes of evil assume power in Britain tomorrow.
Labels:
conservatives,
david cameron,
police,
scumbags,
tories
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

